Everybody loves rankings, right? There's no better way to start a pointless argument than to rank items that hold unique, special places to each collector. Once upon a time, I tried to write up a completely objective ranking of the original 13 Joe figures. But, even with the stated goal of erasing childhood nostalgia from the equation, the list was pretty much my personal favorites with a few guys bumped up a spot or two. So, why bother with any of that pretext? Instead, I'm going with a straight ranking of my favorite figures: starting with the original 13. I'm only using swivel arm versions as I don't collect straight arms. And, I'll do the "new" 1983 figures some other time. I'm not sure I'll get to every year because I'll get bored of it long before I would ever endeavor to slog through all the 1993 releases. But, I'm going to start with the year that's sure to elicit some opinions.
The thing is, there are no wrong opinions about these figures. If Short Fuse holds dear, core memories for you, that's a story worth telling in the comments. The point of this isn't to challenge your beliefs. Instead, it's to memorialize mine and prompt a modicum of discussion. So, on with the show....
#13 - Short Fuse
I just can't get into Short Fuse. He was never a player in my collection. He didn't have much of a characterization in the comic other than being an annoying hot head. And, his weapon wasn't conducive to childhood play. But, really, he's kind of boring. His chests harness isn't the greatest design. But, he's also in a green that's similar to other figures. So, you don't really feel like you're getting anything special with this figure. Zap is a better use of the mold. Hawk is a better use of the head. I know we had one when I was a kid. But, mostly, I remember him from the fact that I noticed his mortar mold changed and it was also knocked off by, I think, Galoob for some of their action figure lines. That's not much of a legacy.
#12 - Grunt
I'm not a Grunt fan. Never have been. I've always found him to be boring. To be fair, I missed the silver knife on his chest...a feature that captivated me when we got a Tan Grunt in 1983. But, I still see this guy as just a basic infantryman. His M-16 never clicked with me, either. It broke thumbs in 1982. I did love his backpack. I gave it to Clutch so I didn't waste it on Grunt. There's not much too him and he lacks the skills to really set himself apart from his more specialized team mates. At some point in late 1982 or early 1983, we buried a bunch of Joes behind some bricks that lined the stairs up the hill in our front yard. I remember pulling a well worn Grunt and Stalker out of the space a few years later. That's about the extent of his use. He and Short Fuse remain my least used figures of the original series of Joes.
#11 - Hawk
Let's face two facts. Visually, Grunt is a better figure than Hawk. And, the debut figure of Joe's leader kind of sucks. But, I give Hawk the edge over Grunt due to the silver trim dominating the figure. It gives him a more commanding presence. And, the over abundance of silver does give Hawk a defining look. There's not much else going on here, though. So, he ranks pretty low. I snapped the thumb of my 1982 Hawk when I tried to give him a Battle Gear M-16. After that, the character disappeared until the amazing 1986 upgrade came around. Hawk looks good. But, if I want to use Hawk, I'll almost never choose this figure.
#10 - Grand Slam
Grand Slam and Flash share the same mold. The darker green on Grand Slam is a definite downgrade over the brighter green that Flash uses. As a kid, we only had a straight arm Grand Slam. The Silver Pads version was my Grand Slam. I used him as a derivative of Flash, though. The lack of accessories drops Grand Slam down a bit. But, this figure does get a lot more use from me now. Mostly, that's due to the fact that Grand Slam has remained pretty obscure over the years. And, he's a guy who holds a certain, undeserved reputation for being rarer than other figures. This is a function of the Silver Pads version. But, photos with this original Grand Slam tend to do well since people don't see him all that often. I definitely use this guy more than this low ranking would suggest.
#09 - Breaker
Breaker was my first Joe. It pains me to rank him this low. But, Breaker kind of marks a point in the line where every figure from here on out is pretty strong. I ended up ranking him lower because there's not a lot of paint on him and he lacks a firearm. That's made up for by his strong accessories, though. His communications headset might be my favorite single accessory from the original 13. And, it was a staple of my Joe world: even long after Breaker had fallen apart. He's a mainstay in my HQ: helming the computer console. And, I even use him as the second passenger in the VAMP. Breaker remains a nostalgic favorite. And, his low rank is just indicative of how strong the first wave of Joes was.
#08 - Snake Eyes
Yeah, I get it. The "all black" was a design choice. But, it's also limiting on this figure. And, the 1997 and later repaints that added just one or two paint applications showed that just a little bit of color would break this guy up and make for a better figure. But, Snake Eyes also features some unique parts. The bomb on his leg is a feature that's really ignored and speaks to the figure's intentions of being a commando instead of a super human ninja. His gear was also pretty strong. The Uzi is synonymous with Snake Eyes and remains a mainstay of the character to this day. There is something about the all black appearance of the original design that is lost when you paint up some details. But, were this figure not super popular and somewhat expensive, he'd have little reason to be used over the later repaints of this mold.
#07 - Zap
My youngest brother got a Zap when he went to visit my grandparents in early 1983. Before the figure came home, both Zap's thumbs were broken. So, Zap wasn't a part of our childhood collection. But, he's a figure whose importance grew as an adult collector. Very early on in my collecting journey, I got obsessed over Zap. So, he was among the only early figures I sought out to add to my collection in 1999-2000. He didn't disappoint. His unique color and strong gear add up to a fun figure. Were mine not suffering from a snapped o-ring and stuck back screw, I'd use him in photos much more often. No later homage to this original Zap was able to live up to this original version. (Though, the Super Sonic Fighters Zap is among the better character upgrades Hasbro ever did.) The swivel arm version remains expensive due to the ubiquity of snapped thumbs. But, he's worth having around.
#06 - Steeler
If you were missing just one of the original 13 figures back in 1982 and 1983, it was probably Steeler. Being the driver of the line's most expensive vehicle meant he was often absent from otherwise complete collections. Steeler features a unique chest piece. That alone makes him useful. But, he's also a great match for the Mauler and Slugger, giving him some versatility among later vehicles that was often lacking from his contemporaries. His binocular helmet attachment was neat and gave him more visual distinction. And, he even included an Uzi, something also unique to him as a vehicle driver. I use Steeler more than most of the other original 13 figures. Though, that's also because I have a spare that's easily accessible. But, he's deserving of his spot.
#05 - Scarlett
Scarlett's a tough one. From a sheer design standpoint, she might be the second best figure in the original lineup. Her sculpt is amazingly detailed. And, that's often glossed over. Her unique color really stood out among the sea of Green that was the original wave. And, it allowed her to evolve with the line and remain complementary with figures that were released years later. It's tough to find a Scarlett that hasn't discolored. And, that really limits her. And, the 2003 repaint of this mold was better. Even the 1997 is strong, though, it's very different from the 1982 coloring. So, her lower ranking here is a function of those later figures being more interesting than the first design.
#04 - Clutch
Clutch was my favorite Joe right from the get go. His unique chest with the holstered pistol was a drawing point. I gave him a visor, Stalker's gun and Grunt's backpack to make him the most badass fighter the Joes would ever see. Years later, even a straight arm Clutch retained relevance in my collection because he was so well done. He's at home when he's behind the wheel of any early Joe vehicle. And, you can use him sans vehicle as well. I still refer to this head sculpt as the "Clutch" head as I feel he owned the design the best and made it his own.
#03 - Stalker
Stalker stands out due to his cammo pattern. It was a unique look among the original figures. And, it gave him depth beyond the reuse of the standard grenade and knife torso. His head also featured a sculpted head covering with his green beret. It made the figure a quick favorite. The prominence of the character in the comic helped hold him over and made Stalker among the more popular characters in the line. Stalker had a ton of great character updates. (I'll maintain the '89 Stalker is one of the best updates any character ever got.) But, none of them treaded over this original version. Even today, an original Stalker can intermingle with figures from all years and not look out of place. I wish the Comic Pack versions had been better. But, we have the 1997 figure, which might be even better than the 1983. Any way you look at it, though, the combo of figure and character puts Stalker near the top.
#02 - Flash
Flash is the best designed figure of the original 13. He features a nice shade of green on his base layer. He is then accentuated by a brilliant red chest, leg and arm pads. These give him a startling appearance among his peers. Were that not enough, though, the entirety of the red is outlined by a silver trim. All of these colors carry over to his back, too. In short, the sculpting was miles ahead of what other toy lines were doing. And, then, Hasbro gave us the real kicker: his accessories. Flash got the standard helmet. But, you really get the impression that the standard clear visor was actually designed for Flash first and then ported to other figures. His backpack is an intricate mess of technology. And, it all culminates in a laser rifle that can plug into the pack. The combo of sculpting, color and gear makes Flash tough to beat. In fact, he should be number 1. But, he's beat out for one simple reason that you'll see next.
#01 - Rock and Roll
Rock and Roll isn't the best figure among the original 13. But, he's the one I use the most. Part of it is that his simplicity works for his specialty. But, he also features a unique torso and an amazing weapon. I happen like the character, too. I remember Rock and Roll as the crazed madman from "Hot Potato" in the first issue of the comic. But, he later became a bit more mellow. And, this made him interesting. He was supposed to be "replaced" by Roadblock. But, he stayed on the team and remained an integral part of the story until the very end. The gold bullets really make Rock and Roll stand out. And, it gives him more bulk, even if he's the same size as the rest of his friends. I use this figure constantly. I bought a spare just so I could use him more often. It happened to the mail away version, which was a nice surprise. (Things like that used to happen all the time.) So, Rock and Roll gets my top spot just because he's a guy who resonates with me and gets used all the time. It's no more complicated than that.





Unpopular opinion. I don't like any of the OG 13
ReplyDeletedon't worry...I feel the same.
DeleteI would move SE up one spot, maybe another over Scarlett…and I would move Steeler up ahead of both of them. Otherwise, I pretty much agree with your rankings. Well, maybe I would put Flash over RnR. The main thing that hurts Scarlett for me was her lack of foot pegs.
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to your future lists!
I would move Hawk down a point, maybe move Grand Slam down a point, and move Stalker up a point, but nothing on this list is poorly argued. I am a little forgiving of Grunt in that he is, to an extent, meant to be unremarkable. Still makes him difficult to work into things, though. In both Marvel and Sunbow, his most famous story is the one where he leaves the team.
ReplyDeleteOf course I belong to the wrong demographic wave of G.I. Joe fans to fully appreciate the original thirteen.
Perhaps for future years you can limit them to just a Top 10 or 15?
ReplyDeleteClutch was my first G.I. Joe figure and still my favorite of the entire line. I originally had a straight-arm bought right in 1982, and later replaced it with the even better swivel-arm version.
My least favorite from this wave is Hawk. Just a very bland figure recycling parts from the others, with nothing at all distinctive to mark him as leader of the team. Plus, his blonde hair contradicts all future versions of the character (except in the Hama comics, which continue to keep him as blonde no matter what the action figures look like).
I might consider it. But, Timmer did all the 1993 figures. So, I feel I have to, too. But, there's so many of them that I've never owned that the bottom 1/5 will just be unranked.
DeleteGreat idea for a write-up. Last year I tried (again) to collect the OG13 figures (swivel arm not straight arm) but about halfway through I just realized that for the most part they don't draw me in like the rest of the line. Cost, fragility and age of the plastic also led to me ending the endeavor. I suppose that is rooted in the fact my Joe heyday was the late 80s through the end of the line. With that said although the OG13 don't completely resonate with me I certainly appreciate the significance of the original figures and the foundation they laid for the ARAH run which in my opinion is the best toy line ever created.
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to separate the objective analysis of the figures with my love of the GI Joe line. As mentioned above I did attempt to collect the line last year but ended up selling most of the figures off. Of course there are exceptions and I did hold onto Rock N' Roll and Steeler as I very much like both those figures and couldn't bring myself to offload them. Steeler was needed as tank driver and Rock N' Roll is just awesome. I agree with your assessment of Rock and Roll as the top overall figure, he's awesome. I'd put Stalker at number 2 with Steeler at 3.
My rankings would be :
1. Rock N' Roll
2. Stalker
3. Steeler
4. Zap
5. Flash
6. Grunt
7. Snake-Eyes
8.Grand Slam
9.Short Fuse
10. Hawk
11. Clutch
12. Breaker
13. Scarlett
When I began reading the paragraph on Zap my thoughts went immediately to my childhood Zap which was the Sonic Fighters version - just an awesome figure and a great example of how the line evolved over the years. Same goes for Clutch - love the Mega Marine version but the original doesn't move the needle for me.
I think the closest I will ever get to the OG13 is the 1997 Stars and Stripes set if I ever decide to acquire it again as I mentioned in your 1997 Grunt post from a few weeks ago. I also have the Super 7 Reaction+ Flash on preorder, I actually feel that the Super 7 Reaction+ figures and their construction are more in the spirit of the early ARAH line with the less bulky construction. Hope that isn't blasphemous.
Great idea. I might do one myself!
ReplyDeleteYour top 3 is the same as mine, and all three are such great figures that they are almost interchangeable for the ranking
I never actually thought of actually ranking the OG 13 so let me try:
ReplyDelete1.Flash- by a country mile. Having a visor and a cord connected laser rifle just looked too cool.
2.Clutch - boy I could relate to how he didnt get along with Scarlett, much like I didnt get along with the girls in school. He came with an amazing vehicle and I like the pistol/holster mold.
3.Snake Eyes - nuff said. That said, without his incredible comic book characterization he would rank lower objectively.
4. Rock n Roll 's amazing weapon guarantees an early entry. Unique mold helps a lot.
5. Steeler- always a favorite of mine. I think he inspired me to join the army as a tank crewman M1 Abrams.
6.Breaker- I like the headset backpack combo.
7.Zap- broke the thumbs like everybody else, love the rpg he has.
8.Short Fuse- Maybe it's nostalgia more than anything else.
9.Stalker- he could go up a few spots depending on the day. Really likeable character in the comic and I love his weapon
10.Grand Slam- not as cool as Flash. Silver pads would rank A LOT higher.
11.Hawk- boring figure, but he was competent at least in the Marvel run.
12.Grunt-really the ultimate Greenshirt. Talk about generic. Last seen chatting up a college cutie on the GI Bill.
13. Scarlett- ugly head mold and quite the nasty person in the comics. Never liked her. You can't even stand her up for display. Speaking of Super7, I hope they knock the o-ring version out of the park.
Great post. I didn't know there was a mail away version of R&R.
ReplyDeleteHe was part of the "Original Action Team" or something. The main indicator is green rivets. Though, the European releases on the white Action Force cards also had them. There's a ton of variants in this set on both swivel arm '82's and some '83 figures. Zap is especially noticeable.
DeleteI've been wanting to do a Rarities post on them for some time. Probably just need to suck it up and do it.
Things have been reduced to ranking lists. Where's Destro is my Spirit Animal? That's all that dude does.
ReplyDelete13- Scarlett, nice they made the chick in the first wave but why the gymnastic outfit? It became an iconic look, but it's still like why? Why the big head?
12- Grand-Slam, named after the breakfast his mom ate at Denny's when she was pregnant with him.
11- Hawk, silver rubs off and if he weren't leader, he'd have been the most underused Joe in the media.
10- Short-Fuse, you can't really make an indirect weapons specialist a major player and it showed in media. Figure is fine, mortar is so-so.
9- Zap, this is unfair, but, yes, the thumb breaking bazooka handles hurt him as a toy.
8- Flash, flash...he saved everyone of us. Those spats, though,...I dunno about those.
7- Snake-Eyes, same, the bad arse with spats over boots. The lack of paint, much celebrated, is cheap ass and lame but Hasbro was budget conscious in year one. Year two do-over has no excuse.
6- Steeler, his mold says "I'm the leader" but Hama even forgot he made Steeler an officer. Better than the vehicle he came with which reduced him compared to...
5- Clutch, named after his mom's purse. Still call women chicks, like many of us. It's our polite term. LOL
4- Breaker, need that gun, but it held off his thumbs getting broken.
3- Rock & Roll. Why was he a darker green? Why not, I guess.
2- Stalker, my older brother's fav OG joe. I'd almost automatically rank him lower due to Hama's favoritism of him, but it's good figure.
1- Grunt, as a basic infantryman from the US midwest, he is GI JOE personified...everyone thinking otherwise is wrong. LOL. But yeah, I absolutely broke both thumbs and was reduced to operating the RAM or Whirlwind.
Very good list. And good lists from everyone in the comments. All varied with reason. If this was YouTube, Snake Eyes would be at the top. Nothing wrong with that choice. But it's always the same.
ReplyDeleteFor me, 1982-1984 are the best years of G.I.*Joe with the swivel versions of 1982 lineup being the best. Sure, you can broad stroke them and say they are all the same. But even though they share parts and colors, as Mike has laid out above, they are all different from each other. The unique chests and accessories add so much and the clear visors are a thing of beauty.
Anyway, my ranking for now. As me in 5 minutes and will be different.
13 - Grunt
12 - Short-Fuze
11 - Scarlett
10 - Hawk
9 - Snake Eyes
8 - Zap
7 - Breaker
6 - Clutch
5 - Steeler
4 - Grand Slam
3 - Rock 'n Roll
2 - Stalker
1 - Flash
Flash is the man. Like many he was my first Joe. The orange pads were so striking and stood out from all the figures on the toy isle at Montgomery Wards. He was the reason I got Joes as a kid and again kicked off my collecting again 6 years ago. He will always top the list. But Firefly is my favorite.....